Rival Hypothesis
Rubric for Discussion unit 6
Criteria 1 Initial Response Quality
● Responds in well-developed paragraphs that exceed specified length requirements
● Responds to all questions in the prompt and remains on-topic
● Applies and references relevant course material
● Includes a relevant, open-ended question
Criteria 2 – Engagement With Others
● Responds to three or more classmates’ initial posts
● Responds to at least one follow-up response by instructor or classmates
● Applies and references relevant course material
Criteria 3 – APA Style
● Contribution to the discussion includes asking relevant
questions and/or providing situational examples
● Applies APA style to credit sources, when needed, with no errors
● Uses language appropriate to the writing context
● Uses inclusive and respectful language
Criteria 4 – Writing conversation
● Demonstrates control of language, sentence variety, and complexity
● Applies editing skills to ensure few or no grammar or punctuation errors
For this week’s discussion, you will find a credible source that either presents a rival perspective to your argument for change or will help you address a rival hypothesis that you identified in the Unit 4 Assignment. Then, you will share a key passage from the source that is relevant to the rival hypothesis and paraphrase that information using a signal phrase and in-text citation. Respond to the following prompts in at least two well-developed paragraphs (not including the copied-and-pasted material from your secondary source):
1. Identify the rival hypothesis you need to address in your essay.
2. Describe the rival source you found and why you selected that source. What makes this a credible source?
3. Copy and paste a 1–5 sentence passage from the source and label it as the “Original Passage.”
4. Paraphrase the short passage you shared in a way that you might use the idea in your essay (for example, refute the rival hypothesis). Be sure to use in-text citations with any sentences paraphrasing ideas from the source, e.g., (Doe, 2013) or According to Jane Doe (2013). Remember from your reading that an effective paraphrase sets up the information and explains it in a way that connects it to your argument (Krause, 2007).
5. Ask an open-ended question related to how you can effectively address the disagreement in your argument or related to paraphrasing and using sources.
6. At the end of your post, provide a complete Reference page citation in APA style for the source.
