Journal Article Review Instructions
Select the Article: Choose a quantitative, qualitative, or mixed-methods research article from a reputable academic journal in your field of interest.
Read the Article Thoroughly: Start by reading the entire article carefully. Make notes as you read to keep track of key points and your initial impressions.
Sections of Your Review
Title Page
(separate page) Format it according to the APA Style format
Abstract (separate page)
The abstract section of a journal article review provides a concise and comprehensive summary of the reviewed article. It serves as a snapshot of the entire review, highlighting the most critical aspects of the study.
In this section, you should begin by mentioning the full title of the article and the authors’ names. Then, briefly introduce the main research problem, objectives, and the significance of the study. You may also mention the research methods employed, the key findings, and the implications of the study.
It’s essential to maintain brevity while encapsulating the essential elements of the article, as the abstract should serve as a quick reference for readers to understand the study’s focus and your assessment of it. The tone should be neutral and objective, conveying the main points while avoiding overly detailed analysis. Your abstract should entice readers to delve deeper into your full review for a more comprehensive evaluation of the article.
Title and Introduction
Begin your review by providing the full title of the article and the names of the authors. Summarize the article’s introduction, highlighting the research problem, objectives, and the significance of the study.
Methodology
Describe the research methods used in the study, including the study design, data collection procedures, and data analysis techniques.
Assess the appropriateness and rigor of the methodology. Consider the following: Sample size and selection.
Data collection tools and techniques. Data analysis methods.
Ethical considerations.
Results
Summarize the main findings of the study, including any statistical tests or analyses conducted.
Present numerical results, tables, charts, or graphs that are relevant to the study’s findings.
Discuss whether the results support the research hypothesis or research questions.
Discussion
Evaluate the authors’ interpretation of the results. Are the conclusions drawn logically and supported by the data?
Analyze the strengths and weaknesses of the study, particularly with respect to the methodology.
Assess the generalizability of the findings and their implications for the broader field. Consider any limitations and potential biases in the study.
Implications for Further Research
In this section of your quantitative journal article review, you will discuss the implications of the reviewed study for future research. Follow these guidelines:
Summarize Key Findings: Begin by summarizing the key findings and conclusions of the study. This will provide a context for discussing future research directions.
Identify Gaps and Limitations: Discuss any limitations or gaps in the current study. What aspects of the research were not covered or could be explored in more depth?
Consider any potential biases or shortcomings in the methodology that may inform future research design.
Conclusion
Summarize your overall assessment of the article.
Discuss the article’s contributions to the field and its potential impact on future research. Offer your own perspective on the significance of the study and its strengths and weaknesses.
References
(separate page) List your references following APA formatting.
Formatting and Style:
Ensure your review adheres to the specific guidelines provided by your instructor, department, or the journal you’re submitting it to.
Use a formal and scholarly tone in your writing.
Proofread and Edit:
Carefully proofread your review to eliminate grammatical, spelling, and formatting errors.
Ensure clarity and coherence in your writing.
Cite Your Sources:
If you use any external sources to support your analysis, make sure to cite them appropriately using the citation style specified by your instructor or journal guidelines.
Remember that a well-structured and well-reasoned review is not just a summary of the article but a critical analysis that helps the reader understand the strengths and weaknesses of the research. Your review should contribute to the ongoing scholarly conversation in your field.